August 13, 2009 — vol. 45, no 1
In N.H., Obama tackles health care critics
PORTSMOUTH, N.H. — Braced for a fight he never got, President Barack Obama went on the offensive in support of his health care plan on Tuesday, urging a town hall audience not to listen to those who seek to “scare and mislead the American people.”“For all the scare tactics out there, what is truly scary is if we do nothing,” Obama told a friendly crowd of about 1,800 in a high school auditorium and a nationwide audience watching on cable television.
The White House had been ready for an unruly reception from opponents of overhauling health care. There was no sign of that, perhaps because of the makeup of the day’s crowd or out of traditional deference for the president.
Obama’s push came amid a string of disruptive health care town halls nationwide that have overshadowed his message and threatened to derail support in Congress.
Indeed, Republican-turned-Democratic Sen. Arlen Specter faced hostile questions, taunts and jeers earlier on Tuesday as he tried to explain his positions at a town hall in Lebanon, Pa. Voter fears of a government takeover of health care were on stark display.
Some lawmakers, holding forums during Congress’ August recess, have gone so far as to replace public forums with teleconferences or step up security to keep protesters at bay.
But the Democratic president faced no outbursts.
The encounter was so friendly, in fact, that by the end Obama was even asking for skeptical questioners to come forward — to no avail.
He told his audience reassuringly, “For all the chatter and the yelling and the shouting and the noise, what you need to know is this … if you do have health insurance, we will make sure that no insurance company or government bureaucrat gets between you and the care you need.”
Retooling his message amid sliding support, he addressed some of his remarks to a vital and skeptical audience: the tens of millions of people who already have health insurance and are generally satisfied with the care they get.
He said the overhaul is essential to them, too, contending that it is the way to keep control in their hands. Obama said while government bureaucrats should not meddle with people’s care, bureaucrats at insurance companies should not, either.
The president accused critics of creating “boogeymen.”
“Spread the facts. Let’s get this done,” Obama implored the crowd.
The tone was set as soon as Obama arrived. He came in to applause and told one person who shouted support, “I love you back.”
One man identified himself as a Republican and said, “I don’t know what I’m doing here.” The Democratic president said he was happy to have him in attendance.
Toward the end of the session, Obama went so far as to ask people to give him skeptical questions. The best he got were queries about why he doesn’t chastise Congress more and where the nation would find the additional doctors and nurses it needs.
Heading toward a pivotal fall debate before congressional action, Obama is scrambling to get lawmakers and the public behind what would be the most ambitious and costly changes to the health care system in decades.
He reiterated his determination that the plan will be paid for without adding to the nation’s soaring deficit.
He took on what he described as erroneous claims that have arisen as the debate in Washington and the nation has developed.
He singled out the charge that the Democratic health care legislation would create “death panels” to deny care to frail seniors, an assertion that has been made by former Alaska governor and Republican vice presidential candidate Sarah Palin.
Obama declared that a provision that he said had caused the uproar would only authorize Medicare to pay doctors for counseling patients about end-of-life care, living wills, hospice care and other issues if the patients wanted it.
It would not “basically pull the plug on grandma because we decided that it’s too expensive to let her live anymore,” as Obama put it.
The people Obama called on for questions asked him largely about their personal medical concerns and how any new law would affect them.
“We’re not talking about cutting Medicare benefits,” he said, trying to reassure one questioner.
Obama sought to dispel talk that his ultimate goal is a single-payer federal health care system, like that in countries such as Canada.
He also disputed the notion that adding a government-run insurance plan into a menu of options from which people could pick would drive private insurers out of business, in effect making the system single-payer by default.
As long as they have a good product and the government plan has to sustain itself through premiums and other non-tax revenue, private insurers should be able to compete with the government plan, Obama said.
“They do it all the time,” he said. “UPS and FedEx are doing just fine. … It’s the Post Office that’s always having problems.”
(Associated Press)
related articles
Excerpts from President Obama's remarks in Portsmouth, N.H., on health care reform
"... I don't have to explain to you that nearly 46 million Americans don't have health insurance coverage today," President Barack Obama said. "In the wealthiest nation on Earth, 46 million of our fellow citizens have no coverage." More »
From FDR to Obama, a fight for health care
Since Franklin Delano Roosevelt considered national health care in the 1930s, virtually every president has sought to expand or universalize medical coverage. Public support has been as consistent as the countering arguments — it costs too much, it doesn’t have the votes, it will ruin the free market system. More »
Private health care coverage at 50-year low
The percentage of Americans with private health
insurance has hit its lowest mark in 50 years, according to two new
government reports. About 65 percent of non-elderly Americans had private insurance in
2008, down from 67 percent the year before, according to preliminary
data released by the U.S. Centers for Disease Control
and Prevention. More »
Upfront costs complicate Obama's health care plan
Costs are emerging as the biggest obstacle to President Barack Obama’s ambitious plan to provide health insurance for everybody. The upfront tab could reach $1.2 trillion to $1.5 trillion over 10
years, while expected savings from wringing waste and inefficiency from
the health care system may take longer to show. More »
