Mayor Thomas M. Menino addresses the crowd at the New Bostonian Community Day, held at City Hall on Wednesday, Sept. 23, 2009. The previous day, Menino got 51 percent of the vote in the preliminary mayoral election. City Councilor-at-Large Michael F. Flaherty (24 percent) will face Menino in November. (Photo courtesy of the Mayor’s Press Office)
Faced with two hotly contested citywide races, Boston voters cleaved largely along race lines in last Tuesday’s preliminary election.
While racially divided voting patterns are not new in Boston, the trend of increasing turnout in the city’s black, Latino and Asian communities continued last week, with two blacks and two Latinos advancing onto the November ballot.
In the race for mayor, incumbent Mayor Thomas M. Menino won handily with 50.5 percent of the vote, according to unofficial results released by the city’s Elections Department. At-large city councilors Michael F. Flaherty and Sam Yoon received 24 percent and 21 percent, respectively. As the second-leading vote-getter, Flaherty will move on to challenge Menino in November.
Flaherty did well in the city’s predominantly white ethnic precincts, while Menino did better among black voters. The 64 percent of the vote that the mayor received in Roxbury outmatched the 61 percent that Flaherty received in South Boston.
Yoon polled well in white liberal neighborhoods, but fell short in his bid to unseat Menino.
He’ll still be a part of the equation, however. In a press conference held Tuesday morning at City Hall Plaza, Yoon and Flaherty appeared to announce that they would campaign together in the weeks prior to the Nov. 3 election. If he wins, Flaherty has said he will appoint Yoon as his deputy mayor, with responsibilities including oversight of a computerized review of city services and the dismantling of the Boston Redevelopment Authority, a controversial issue throughout the mayoral campaign.
In the at-large race, ticket-topping incumbents John R. Connolly, who garnered 35,115 votes, and Stephen J. Murphy, who received 30,311, won big in the city’s predominantly Irish Catholic neighborhoods. The sitting at-large councilors led the balloting in South Boston, the white Dorchester enclaves of Savin Hill, Neponset and Cedar Grove, West Roxbury, Charlestown and South Boston.
Meanwhile, challengers Felix Arroyo, Tito Jackson and Ayanna Pressley received the most votes in Roxbury, Dorchester and the predominantly black and Latino parts of the South End, Jamaica Plain and Hyde Park.
Arroyo, who placed third behind Connolly and Murphy with 25,821 votes, won more wards — 4, 8, 9, 10, 11, 14, 15, 17 and 19 — than any other candidate, winning every predominantly black and/or Latino ward in the city except Roxbury’s Ward 12, where he finished second behind Jackson.
Arroyo also won the precincts in Chinatown.
Pressley did not win a single ward but finished in the middle of the pack in just about every ward in the city, placing higher in the black, Latino and liberal white precincts.
Her 16,846 votes put her behind Arroyo in the fourth slot, leaving her well-positioned to gain a seat on the City Council in the November final.
Jackson, making his first run for elected office, finished as the sixth of eight candidates who will appear on the November ballot, earning 12,520 votes — just 112 fewer than fifth-place finisher Andrew Kenneally.
Behind Jackson were former Nantucket selectman Doug Bennett with 10,519 votes and Tomas Gonzalez, a former Latino community liaison for Menino, who drew 10,108 votes.
The strong showing from black and Latino candidates followed weeks of door-knocking, literature drops and outreach from well-organized, well-financed campaigns. Several debates sponsored by local nonprofits and news organizations, including the Banner, also helped spur voters’ interest in the race, according to political activist Mimi Jones.
“When I went to my first forum, my mind was wide open,” she said. “When I went into the voting booth, I had narrowed it down to four.”
Turnout in the city’s black, Latino and Asian neighborhoods matched the citywide average of 23 percent, according to an analysis released Monday by MassVOTE. By comparison, West Roxbury saw 35 percent turnout. The higher turnout in the predominantly white ethnic neighborhoods gave incumbents Connolly and Murphy an enviable boost.
Connolly garnered 6,163 votes in West Roxbury — more than Arroyo received in wards 8, 9, 12, 14, 16 and 17 combined.
But the leads enjoyed by Connolly and Murphy in the preliminary could very well shrink in the November election, when higher percentages of black, Latino, Asian and liberal white voters are likely to go to the polls.
In the 2005 election, Arroyo’s father, Felix D. Arroyo, rocketed from a fifth-place preliminary finish to second place in the final, coming within 5,000 votes of at-large leader Flaherty.
The fact that two blacks and two Latinos will be vying for voters’ four choices along with three Irish candidates and newcomer Bennett could also draw away votes that would normally go to the white incumbents.
In the mayor’s race, Menino’s bulletproof name recognition may be what ultimately gave him such a wide margin of victory over his challengers, according to political activist Sarah-Ann Shaw, who serves as secretary on the Ward 12 Democratic Committee.
“He comes to a lot of events in the community,” Shaw said. “He shows up. It’s very hard to unseat an incumbent because they have a certain amount of media access that a challenger doesn’t have.”
Media access didn’t provide enough of a boost for Carlos Henriquez to outpace incumbent Chuck Turner in their race for the District 7 City Council seat.
Turner received 52.6 percent of the vote to 23.9 percent for Henriquez, who received endorsements from the Boston Herald and Boston Globe before the preliminary. Perennial candidates Althea Garrison and Roy Owens received 14 percent and 9 percent of the vote, respectively.
The city Elections Department's Web site has complete unofficial results from the preliminary elections for mayor, the at-large and district seats on Boston's City Council. More »
With the Sept. 22 preliminary elections just one week away, candidates for at-large City Council seats tried to differentiate themselves from their 14 rivals, answering questions on schools, CORI reform and city revenues at a forum held Tuesday night at the Harriet Tubman House on Columbus Avenue. More »
In the last year, Chuck Turner has been arrested at his City Hall office and become embroiled in a very public battle with the U.S. Attorney's Office over charges that he took a bribe. More »
Emotions ran high at Roxbury Community College's Reggie Lewis Track and Athletic Center, as Boston's four mayoral candidates squared off in the first of three citywide forums hosted by nonprofit voter advocacy organization MassVOTE. More »