Cornel West calls it quits at Harvard
Move comes after university refused to consider acclaimed professor for tenure
Harvard University Professor Dr. Cornel R. West, who had been threatening a second departure from the Ivy League institution since he was not offered a tenured position last month, announced Monday that he will leave for a post at Union Theological Seminary, where he was first hired at 23 years old.
“I am moving from Harvard to Union Theological Seminary in New York City! Our struggle for truth & justice continues with style & smiles!” the philosopher, author and activist tweeted, with a link to an interview in The Boycott Times.
West, 67, who left his tenured University Chair post in 2002 following a public clash with former Harvard President Lawrence H. “Larry” Summers, returned as a professor of practice of public philosophy at the Harvard Divinity School and in the Department of African and African American Studies in the Faculty of Arts of Sciences in 2017.
“It’s time to go. I can only take so much disrespect,” said West on Tuesday. “I’ve got work to do, and don’t have time for pettiness.”
West said Harvard could have retained him if they had started the tenure process, but that now he is looking forward to moving on after he finishes the semester teaching two law school courses.
“Oh, I’m fired up!” he said of returning to Union.
West’s second departure comes after students and faculty members rallied unsuccessfully to pressure the university to grant him tenure. West and others at Harvard said the university’s decision to not grant him tenure is part of a pattern. Currently, 8% of tenured professors and 13% of tenure-track professors are underrepresented minorities, including Blacks and Latinos.
“Respect is something you can’t just calculate and negotiate. A lot of people have told me ‘Take the money and go, take the money and go, Brother West.’ I said no, I wasn’t raised like that,” West told the Banner last month. “We’ve got something called integrity.”
Harvard senior Injil Muhammad, a member of Harvard Black Men’s Forum, said it’s “a disgrace” that West was not offered tenure.
“I hope that Prof. West is making the best decision for him but I’m really disappointed in the university for not granting him the request that would’ve allowed him to stay,” said Muhammad. “His impact really can’t be overstated as far as how much he helps students really live up to the creed that is intellectual curiosity, and seeking truth, which is the motto of Harvard University,” said Muhammad. “His influence on me has been incredible over the course of my four years.”
West said the love between him and the students is mutual.
“I have a tremendous sense of gratitude to them. It’s been a love fest, it’s a beautiful thing,” he said of his supporters. “They’ve got to keep the pressure on the administration to make sure they’ve got young Black professors and scholars who gain access to the highest levels at Harvard. If I can open doors for the younger generation, then this whole crisis will have been a positive thing.”
West had the backing of the Divinity School and the Faculty of Arts and Sciences, both of which requested he be reviewed for tenure. While a faculty committee recommended West receive tenure, university administrators appeared to block the request.
“On behalf of Harvard Divinity School, we want to express our sadness at the departure of our esteemed colleague, Cornel West,” said David N. Hempton, dean of the faculty of divinity, and David Holland, acting dean of HDS, in a statement. “Since coming to Harvard in 2017 as a jointly appointed Professor of the Practice of Public Philosophy in HDS and FAS, he has made an enormous contribution to our curriculum and to our capacity to address issues of racial justice in the United States and around the world. We had hoped to retain him on our faculty for many years to come.”
At Union, where West previously served from 1977–84, 1987–88 and 2012–16, he will hold the Dietrich Bonhoeffer Chair and teach classes covering philosophy, politics, culture and practice, with a particular focus on the origins and evolution of white nationalism. He will join the faculty on July 1.
“We are thrilled to welcome Dr. West back home to Union, where he started his teaching career, at this time of momentous challenge and opportunity,” said Rev. Dr. Serene Jones, president of Union Theological Seminary, in a statement. “Dr. West lives and breathes the values that Union aims to instill in all of the future leaders, scholars, ministers and activists we educate. His esteemed legacy of engaging the most pressing problems facing our world — including racism, poverty, sexism and so much more — is an inspiration to all, and illustrates the power of faith to create profound change.”
An Outpouring of Support
West has received an outpouring of support from a large coalition of students from various campus organizations who worked together to draft a petition signed by over 1,800 people.
“Harvard has a history of treating its radical and justice-oriented scholars as dispensable. Primarily, Black studies, Indigenous studies, and ethnic studies scholars have been recruited, then discarded as untenured faculty in one-year postdoctoral fellowships, contingent professorships or three-year lecturer positions,” read the petition. “Ultimately, Harvard’s denial of tenure process to Professor West is a testament to Harvard’s continued expulsion of faculty who offer incisive analysis of white supremacy, racial capitalism, Zionism and the military-industrial complex, all of which Professor West fervently critiques.”
“It’s Cornel West. He’s a national figure. Very few other scholars of religion or race, even in the humanities, are as cited or as acclaimed or prolific as I think Cornel West is,” said Harvard senior Ajay Singh, who is part of the Ethnic Studies Coalition at Harvard. “And so, it’s sort of astounding that Professor West wouldn’t even receive consideration for tenure, just given how much of an intellectual giant he is. It just doesn’t make any sense from a meritorious context.”
Harvard has a checkered history of granting tenure to and retaining Black and brown faculty. The institution did not offer a tenured position to any Black professor until Martin Kilson received the distinction in 1969. Derrick Albert Bell Jr. was the first Black professor to be tenured at Harvard Law School in 1971. He left the university in 1991 to protest the lack of women of color on the faculty at the law school.
In his March 8 interview with The Boycott Times, West was critical of the university’s record of granting tenure to people of color.
“Harvard has actually done very well in terms of bringing different peoples of different colors and gender at a high level into the administration,” he was quoted in the reader-funded online publication. “But it does not yet translate on the ground in terms of faculty. It does not yet translate in terms of being able to speak to the seeking of truth amongst the students. We were there together for many years and you can testify to that. And so, in that sense, brother, I’ve got to make my move to the great Union Theological Seminary. My perennial home.”