April 22nd, 2021

A Chauvin conviction still won’t prove the system works

Earl Ofari Hutchinson

Former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin got his day in court. He was able to put on a plausible defense that George’s Floyd’s death did not come at his hands (or knee) but because of Floyd’s prior severe medical conditions. A recent USA Today/Ipsos poll found that a lot of people have had second thoughts about what happened in that deadly encounter. That maybe it was just a case of a cop doing his job.

Despite that, Chauvin may well be convicted of one or more of the charges against him in the slaying of George Floyd. At best, it will be a pyrrhic victory. Yes, Floyd’s family got a monster wrongful death settlement. But the brute fact is that Floyd is dead. His children are fatherless. Chauvin made bail months ago and could travel and live in another state. There was much haggling over whether one of the heavier charges should have been slapped on him. Not one GOP House member backed the George Floyd Police Reform Act.

To get passage, President Biden and the Democrats ran like crazy from any hint that defunding the police would be part of the bill. This was a prime cry of the massive police reform protests in the wake of the Floyd killing.

At worst, the Chauvin saga leaves unanswered the perennially tormenting question of just why is it still near-impossible to fire, let alone arrest, prosecute and convict, cops like Chauvin who wantonly overuse deadly force? Chauvin almost certainly would not have been one of the rare cops hauled before a court docket if tens of millions hadn’t been shocked at the video and heard the audio that showed in graphic, brutal and drawn-out detail Floyd in his death agonies on the ground with Chauvin’s knee on his neck. Even then, if Minneapolis and other cites hadn’t been rocked by furious and even violent protests, Chauvin still may have walked.

Now there’s the trial. Chauvin, like others of the relative handful of cops charged with excessive force had top-gun defense lawyers with lots of experience defending police officers accused of misconduct. Police unions bankroll their defense and spare no expense. While the Minneapolis police union publicly declared it didn’t spring Chauvin on bail or provide for his defense, enough sums were raised to ensure him a first-rate defense.

Chauvin’s defense team had some formidable weapons at hand. They muddied things by showing that Floyd had drugs in his system and that this or a heart condition, or both, was the real cause of his death. They paired that line of attack with the claim that Floyd was combative and that the force Chauvin used was necessary for restraint.

It’s an uphill battle for prosecutors to overcome both pro-police attitudes and negative racial stereotypes. In past studies, Stanford University researchers found that even when many whites are presented with evidence that the criminal justice system is loaded with racial bias toward Blacks, they are more likely to support tough, draconian laws such as three strikes, tough sentencing and increased incarceration.

If Chauvin is indeed convicted of a charge in Floyd’s death, it will be an anomaly. It still won’t wipe out the top-heavy benefits that he and other cops who blatantly use deadly force continue to receive within and without the law.

Earl Ofari Hutchinson is an author and political analyst.